---
title: "Money allocated for science sat in banks while research produced no results, according to the VAP… — ВАП — DecisionGateway"
description: "allegation by ВАП, recorded recently — verbatim quote and source citation."
canonical_url: "https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b"
meta:
  "og:description": "allegation by ВАП, recorded recently — verbatim quote and source citation."
  "og:image": "https://dgw.tmarket.io/og.jpg"
  "og:image:alt": "White network of connected nodes crossed by a timeline on black"
  "og:image:height": "1024"
  "og:image:width": "1024"
  "og:title": "Money allocated for science sat in banks while research produced no results, according to the VAP… — ВАП — DecisionGateway"
  "twitter:image": "https://dgw.tmarket.io/og.jpg"
---

> Index of every page on this site: [llms.txt](https://dgw.tmarket.io/llms.txt)

allegation

# **Money allocated for science sat in banks while research produced no results, according to the VAP audit.**

A allegation by [**ВАП**](https://dgw.tmarket.io/actors/01a1e8e9-a142-7726-b774-f3d01e4f5120). Statements are as reported by the cited publishers — not verified by DecisionGateway.

> *Деньги на науку лежали в банках, а исследования не давали результатов: аудит ВАП*

bessimptomnoPublished 2026-11-11 [ Read source](https://t.me/bessimptomno/39569)

[**ВАП dossier **](https://dgw.tmarket.io/actors/01a1e8e9-a142-7726-b774-f3d01e4f5120)

## **Discussion**

## **Related claims**

[**Questions arose not only about research results but also about grant distribution, the work of scientific councils, and financing through Astana Hub and the "Самғау" fund.**post author · allegation](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a25d-7bf0-9a57-2080e9b5e1f1) [**Some funds lay in bank deposits for years, while others went to projects whose results could not be confirmed.**post author · allegation](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a207-757b-9cf6-517694965973) [**Billions of tenge were allocated for the development of Kazakhstani science, but part of the money never reached research.**post author · statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1e8-7812-9099-9782b0f9897a) [**The share of science in the national economy remains insufficiently high at 0.16% of GDP against a target of 1%.**ВАП · statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1ed0c-d015-7049-8fac-3cd1fd804c9f) [**The Higher Audit Chamber checked the use of 241.9 billion tenge of budget funds and identified large-scale violations.**Высшая аудиторская палата · investigation](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a24b-71c8-9523-86bb10897805) [**Based on the audit results, financial violations were established amounting to 51 billion tenge, and inefficient planning and use of funds amounting to 47 billion tenge.**ВАП · statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1ed0c-d095-7494-99a6-b4182a9388f0)

## **More claims by ВАП**

[**A decision was made to transfer audit materials to law enforcement bodies on 3 additional facts.**statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1ed0c-d0bd-7fae-8bdb-022783ee5b21) [**Materials on 36 cases were transferred to authorized bodies for administrative liability.**statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1ed0c-d0ab-7352-ba6a-e8fdd61814d3) [**Based on the audit results, financial violations were established amounting to 51 billion tenge, and inefficient planning and use of funds amounting to 47 billion tenge.**statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1ed0c-d095-7494-99a6-b4182a9388f0) [**62 billion tenge were directed to 79 program-targeted financing projects without detailed expenditure breakdown.**statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1ed0c-d081-79da-bed8-d208cd44a35a) [**For 545 projects, proposals from economic expertise to reduce financing by about 12 billion tenge were not taken into account.**statement](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1ed0c-d06f-7033-9884-a52c228a7eda)

[All claims by ВАП](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims?claimant_id=01a1e8e9-a142-7726-b774-f3d01e4f5120)

[All claims](https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims)

```json
{"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/#website","@type":"WebSite","description":"Decisions, events and falsifiable forecasts — every claim cited to its public source. Read free.","name":"DecisionGateway","url":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/","publisher":{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/#identity"}},{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b#webpage","@type":"WebPage","description":"allegation by ВАП, recorded recently — verbatim quote and source citation.","name":"Money allocated for science sat in banks while research produced no results, according to the VAP… — ВАП — DecisionGateway","url":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b","breadcrumb":{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b#breadcrumb"},"isPartOf":{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/#website"},"potentialAction":[{"@type":"ReadAction","target":["https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b"]}]},{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/#identity","@type":"Organization","name":"DecisionGateway","url":"https://dgw.tmarket.io"},{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b#breadcrumb","@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","name":"Home","item":"https://dgw.tmarket.io","position":1},{"@type":"ListItem","name":"Claims","item":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims","position":2},{"@type":"ListItem","name":"Money allocated for science sat in banks while research…","position":3}]},{"@id":"https://dgw.tmarket.io/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b#/schema/quotation/1","@type":"Quotation","dateCreated":"2026-11-11","isBasedOn":"https://t.me/bessimptomno/39569","text":"Деньги на науку лежали в банках, а исследования не давали результатов: аудит ВАП","url":"/claims/01a1e8e9-a1b8-734f-af29-7aaf0080128b","spokenByCharacter":{"@type":"Person","name":"ВАП","@id":"/actors/01a1e8e9-a142-7726-b774-f3d01e4f5120"}}]}
```

## Sitemap

See the full [sitemap](https://dgw.tmarket.io/sitemap.md) for all pages.
